The oldest public wildflower garden in the United States
Chinkapin Oak (Chinquapin Oak, Chestnut Oak, Yellow Oak)
Quercus muehlenbergii Engelm.
Historical - not extant.
Late spring flowering
The Oaks of the genus Quercus account for more tree biomass than any other species in North America and Mexico (1). Chinkapin Oak is a medium size to large native deciduous tree, growing 50 to 80 feet in height and 2 to 3 feet in diameter, with slightly narrow but rounded crown. It can also be shrubby in certain environments. The National Champion (2019) is located in Rockingham VA measuring 66 feet high, 113 foot crown spread, 287 inches in circumference and scoring 381 points. There are no known large specimens in Minnesota any longer other than those at the Minnesota Landscape Arboretum, which were planted in the 1960s.
Bark is thin, light gray, scaly and shallowly fissured on older trunks.
Twigs are reddish-brown turning gray in the 2nd year, of slender to moderate stoutness, white dotted, with sparse fine hair in the green stage initially which is then lost. Buds are brown to reddish-brown, almost round to ovoid appearing above the leaf scars. Lateral buds are held tight against the twig while there will be multiple small rounded terminal buds, also reddish-brown which may have some fine hair on the scales.
Leaves: Leaves occur only on the current years twigs and are obovate to oblong in shape, up to 7 inches long and half as wide, widest just above the middle, with a dark green leathery upper surface and a much paler underside. Leaf margins undulate with either teeth or shallow lobes, the teeth or lobes are rounded or more acutely upward pointed. Sinuses are lacking. Leaf bases are truncate to cuneate (wedge-shaped). Secondary leaf veins usually number 10 to 14. The underside of the leaf lacks tufts of straight hairs found in some other oaks but can have appressed stellate hairs.
Flowers: The tree is monoecious, that is with separate male and female flowers. The male flowers develop as hanging catkins from the leaf axils of last years' growth. Each male flower has six stamens (can very from 2 to 12), which have long spreading white filaments when the flower fully opens. The female flowers are more reddish-green and appear as small slender spikes in the axils of new growth. They have 3 (to 6) carpels and styles that are slender and short. There are no petals; both sexes have the sepals are fused together. Both develop as the leaves open.
Seed: The female flowers mature to a round, elongated acorn, 1/2 to 1 inch long, 1/4 to 1/2 enclosed in a thin bowl-shaped cap with tightly pressed brown scales tapering to either a very short stalked base or no stalk at all. The scales usually have short gray hair. The nut is light-brown at maturity. They appear either singly or in pairs. The acorn matures in the first year - as do most species in the Quercus Sect. Quercus - the White Oak Group.
Habitat: Chinkapin Oak is one of the most widespread species of trees in temperate North America, not dense coverage, but widespread geographically. It is found in mixed deciduous forests, usually on slopes and in areas of limestone and calcareous soils. It can be found in riparian habitats in western North America. It may hybridize with other Oak species. Shrubby versions do not produce acorns.
Names: The genus name, Quercus, is the Latin word for Oak. The species, muehlenbergii, is an honorary for Gotthilf Heinrich Ernst Muhlenberg (1753-1815) American Botanist who produced several catalogues of plants after retiring as a Lutheran pastor. The author name for the plant classification - ‘Engelm.’ refers to George Engelmann (1809-1884), German-American botanist. Educated in Germany, he came to the U.S. in 1832, undertaking many land exploratory trips of behalf of his uncles in Germany. His botanical notes formed the basis for a number of studies of plants in western North America. His description of this tree was not published until 1897, after his death in 1884. While he earned his living as a medical doctor in St. Louis, his work on Phylloxera found that American vines were immune to it, which proved the savior of the French wine industry in 1870s. The Engelmann Spruce is named for him.
It is called the "Chinkapin Oak" due to the resemblance of its leaves to those of the Ozark and Allegheny Chinkapins of the Castanea genus (Chestnuts). "Yellow Oak" comes from the color of the wood, but it is not very bright. "Chestnut Oak" is again, due to the leaf resemblance to those trees in the Castanea genus.
Comparisons: In years past Chinkapin Oak was divided into 3 varieties under the name Quercus prinoides. Two of those varieties are now assigned to Q. muehlenbergii and one (the shrub form) remains named as Q. prinoides and named the Dwarf Chinkapin Oak or some references may call it the Scrub Chestnut Oak. As said above, Chinkapin Oak in shrub form does not produce acorns whereas the Q. prinoides shrub species produces acorns and spreads clonally which Q. muehlenbergii does not. As a large tree there is a resemblance to Q. bicolor, the Swamp White Oak, but the leaves of that tree have sinuses and blunt tipped lobes.
See bottom of page for notes on the Garden's planting history, distribution in Minnesota and North America, lore and other references.
Below: Twigs are reddish brown initially with white lenticels. Buds are brown to reddish-brown. Lateral buds are tight against the twig, terminal buds are clustered - small and round. 3rd photo - old bark is shallowly fissured.
Below: Leaf margins are lobed or with rounded to pointed tooth. Indentations are shallow - no sinuses. The underside is much paler in color without tufts of hair at the veins.
Below: Leaves form on new twigs only, in a cluster. The upper surface is a glossy leathery green. Fall color is brown.
Below: 1st photo - the male catkins, prior to the flowers opening. 2nd photo - new acorns forming. 3rd photo - mature acorn, photo ©Gary Fewless, University of Wisconsin.
(1) Ascent of the Oaks, Hipp, Manos, Cavender-Bares, SA, Aug 2020.
Eloise Butler introduced Chinkapin Oak to the Garden on May 3, 1922 with three trees from Andrew’s Nursery, in Boulder Co. See used the older name of Quercus prinoides without the variety name, so it is not clear if she planted the dwarf specimens or the tree forms. Neither are known to grow in Colorado so the nursery location still leaves the question unanswered. Chinkapin Oak is found in the United States from northern Mexico, into New Mexico and Texas and the Great Plains eastward excepting upper New England. In Canada, only Ontario has reported it. It is historical in Minnesota with the last known specimen collected in Houston County in 1899. South-eastern Minnesota is on the extreme northwest corner of its range. In Wisconsin it is listed as of 'Special Concern'. It can grow here but winter hardiness is of concern and it needs limestone and calcareous soils such as found in SE Minnesota.
There are six species of Oak generally found in parts of Minnesota that are not considered hybrids or rarities that have not been collected in the last 100 years. These are: White Oak, Q. alba; Swamp White Oak, Q. bicolor; Northern Pin Oak, Q. ellipsoidalis; Bur Oak, Q. macrocarpa; Northern Red Oak, Q. rubra. and Black Oak, Q. velutina. Chinkapin Oak (Chestnut Oak, or Yellow Oak), Q. muhlenbergii was native but is historical only now, last collected in 1899; Scarlet Oak, Quercus coccinea, can also grow here as can Pin Oak, Quercus palustris, but neither are native.
Older Commentary: In his 1817-1819 3 volume North American Sylva, Francois Michaux (Ref.# 26b) wrote: The Yellow Oak is a fine tree, 70 or 80 feet high and 2 feet in diameter, with branches tending rather to close round the trunk than to diffuse themselves horizontally. I invariably found it in valleys where the soil was loose, deep and fertile. The bark upon the trunk is whitish, very slightly furrowed, and sometimes divided into plates, like that of the Swamp White Oak. The wood is yellowish, though the tint is not bright enough to fit it for peculiar uses. Its pores are partly obliterated, irregularly disposed, and more numerous than those of any other American Oak - this organization must impair its strength and render it less durable than the Chesnut White Oak [Swamp Chestnut Oak- Q. michauxii]) and the Rock Chesnut Oak [Chestnut Oak - Q. montana].
As this tree is so thinly disseminated, it will not appear surprising that I should not have witnessed the application of its wood in the arts, or have found occasions of accurately appreciating its qualities. Its agreeable form and beautiful foliage render it proper for the embellishment of picturesque gardens.
As noted above in 'habitat' the tree may be "thinly disseminated" but it is widespread geographically.
References and site links
References: Plant characteristics are generally from sources 1A, 32, W2, W3, W7 & W8 plus others as specifically applied. Distribution principally from W1, W2 and 28C. Planting history generally from 1, 4 & 4a. Other sources by specific reference. See Reference List for details.
Identification booklet for most of the flowering forbs and small flowering shrubs of the Eloise Butler Wildflower Garden. Details Here.
Friends of the Wild Flower Garden, Inc. Text and photos are by G. D. Bebeau unless otherwise credited. "www.friendsofthewildflowergarden.org"